10 Canceled Comic Book Movies That Could Have Ruled The Box Office

There have been many canceled comic book movies from the MCU, the DCU, and various adjacent franchises that could have been huge box office hits had they been made. Over the history of comic book movies, the genre has grown to become the dominant force at the box office. The movies of the MCU, for example, have broken numerous records with their global success, furthering cementing the superhero genre as one of the most popular in modern cinema.

Good essay

Sometimes, however, comic book movies are canceled before they can ever happen. On occasion, an announced movie is scrapped despite having massive potential, and even planned comic book movies that seem certain to achieve box office success go forever unmade. With that in mind, here are 10 canceled comic book movies that could have ruled the box office.

You are watching: 10 Canceled Comic Book Movies That Could Have Ruled The Box Office

10 Channing Tatum’s Gambit Movie Might Have Been Perfect

Tatum Has Proven That He Was Born To Play Gambit

See more : Is Turn of the Tide on Netflix Based on a True Story?

After years of reportedly being considered for the role, Channing Tatum was announced as the star of a Gambit solo movie in 2014. However, the film entered development hell, and ultimately was scrapped in 2019 following Disney’s acquisition of 20th Century Fox. As Channing Tatum was given the opportunity to play the role as part of Deadpool & Wolverine’s cast in 2024, it has become clear just what the actor’s solo Gambit movie could have looked like.

Tatum’s ability to amuse and entertain as Gambit made his appearance one of Deadpool & Wolverine’s best inclusions. The brief time he spent playing the role on screen was the best live-action Gambit to date, proving exactly why Tatum has always been so heavily linked to the role. Had his solo Gambit movie come to fruition, it undoubtedly would have capitalized on both Gambit’s popularity and Tatum’s charisma, likely making it a box office smash.

9 Guillermo Del Toro’s Hellboy 3 Is One Of The Genre’s Biggest Wasted Opportunities

Another Perlman-Led Hellboy Movie Should Have Materialized

See more : Is Turn of the Tide on Netflix Based on a True Story?

Guillermo Del Toro’s reputation as a filmmaker speaks for itself, and his two Hellboy movies are some of the best comic book films of the ‘00s. Ron Perlman’s tenure in the role saw him embody the spirit of the character, bringing Hellboy to life in all his red, grouchy glory. After the success of the first two movies, a third entered production, but ultimately never came to pass.

Considering the huge anticipation surrounding another Perlman-led Hellboy movie, it almost certainly would have found box office success. The combination of Del Toro and Perlman so perfectly fit the world of Mike Mignola’s comics that Hellboy 3 was eagerly awaited by many. The years of built-up anticipation would likely have translated to an impressive box office, but unfortunately the film was scrapped in favor of an ill-fated 2019 reboot.

8 Tim Burton’s Batman Continues Already Sounded Excellent

Burton’s Batman Movies Could Have Continued With A Box Office Smash

See more : Is Turn of the Tide on Netflix Based on a True Story?

1989 saw the release of Tim Burton’s Batman, followed by the sequel, Batman Returns, in 1992. The two films were originally intended to be followed up by a further sequel, reportedly dubbed Batman Continues. However, after concerns about how family-friendly Batman Returns was, the director was asked to step down from the sequel, and Tim Burton’s Batman movies ended after two films. His planned sequel eventually became Batman Forever, but Burton’s original vision had real potential.

Burton had reportedly eyed Robin Williams to play the Riddler and Marlon Wayans as Dick Grayson. Batman Continues also would have brought back Michael Keaton, Michelle Pfeiffer, and Billy Dee Williams, rounding out an excellent ‘90s cast. With so much star power, and as the continuation of a successful franchise, Batman Continues could have earned big money at the box office had it been made in line with Burton’s original plans.

7 The DCEU’s Deathstroke Movie Sounded Fascinating

Unique Ideas Would Have Made Deathstroke A DCEU Hit

See more : Is Turn of the Tide on Netflix Based on a True Story?

Of all the many canceled DCEU projects, the Deathstroke movie may just be the most unique. The film would have paid off the tease from Justice League’s post-credits scene, which saw Jesse Eisenberg’s Lex Luthor meet with Joe Manganiello’s Deathstroke. Manganiello’s solo film was reportedly set to be directed by The Raid director Gareth Evans. Despite barely making it past simply being rumored, the Deathstroke movie was a fascinating prospect.

Gareth Evans’ work on The Raid, combined with Manganiello’s own star power, could have contributed to huge box office success. The action credentials of Evans combined with a DCEU setting and all the support of an existing shared universe could have contributed to a solid box office take for the Deathstroke movie. Though it never made it to the big screen, there was undoubtedly an interesting and unique comic book movie in the DCEUDeathstroke plans.

6 Man Of Steel 2 Was Too Highly Anticipated To Fail

Henry Cavill’s Superman Return Would Have Paid Off Massively

See more : Is Turn of the Tide on Netflix Based on a True Story?

Though Man of Steel was the film that started the DCEU, it never received a direct sequel within the franchise. Though one was initially planned to allow for Henry Cavill to reprise his role in a second solo movie, it was eventually scrapped in favor of the DCU reboot. The canceled Man of Steel sequel was set to feature the villain Brainiac, as well as facilitating further exploration of Cavill’s Man of Tomorrow.

Considering the popularity of Man of Steel and the high profile of the DCEU, it’s safe to say that Man of Steel 2 would have been a success. Zack Snyder’s slightly more grounded approach to the character of Superman was one that many fans enjoyed, particularly as it examined different aspects of the hero. Had Cavill been able to return for Man of Steel 2, the sequel would likely have found success at the box office, even though it was never meant to be.

5 The Amazing Spider-Man 3 Would Have Been A Major Franchise Payoff

Teases For Garfield’s Spider-Man Threequel Made It A Surefire Success

See more : Is Turn of the Tide on Netflix Based on a True Story?

After first appearing in the role in 2012’s The Amazing Spider-Man, Andrew Garfield reprized the role for the 2014 sequel, The Amazing Spider-Man 2. The second film set up many mysteries to be revealed by its own successor, teasing a number of exciting plot points that seemed to promise The Amazing Spider-Man 3 would be the most exciting movie in the franchise. However, The Amazing Spider-Man 3 was ultimately canceled before it could be made.

The planned movie would have seen Peter Parker uncover more of the mystery surrounding his parents, as well as potentially facing off against the Sinister Six. As The Amazing Spider-Man 2 went to great lengths to tease the third film’s story, it seems to be a huge missed opportunity for box office success. What’s more, the talents of Andrew Garfield, Sally Field, and Dane Dehaan would almost certainly have been utilized once again, contributing to even further success.

4 Ben Affleck’s Batman Movie Could Have Been A DCEU High Point

Affleck’s Batman Needed More Exploration In The DCEU

See more : Is Turn of the Tide on Netflix Based on a True Story?

Ben Affleck’s role in the DCEU’s movie timeline was a critical one, despite the fact that he felt severely underused. Making his debut in 2016’s Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, he later appeared in Justice League and The Flash. Affleck’s Batman never starred in his own solo movie, despite one having been in the works with Affleck himself tipped to direct.

See more : What Happened to Rick Manning? Why is Rick Manning Not Broadcasting Today? Where is Rick Manning Now?

An Affleck-driven Batman solo story could have proven to be one of the DCEU’s most profitable entries. In terms of appeal, few characters can boast such widespread popularity as Batman, and Affleck’s own gritty and tortured take on the vigilante was especially good. Though Affleck’s film was scrapped before he got to make his own movie, it likely would have made use of both Affleck’s skill behind a camera and in front of it.

3 Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man 4 Would Have Expanded On His Incredible Vision

Another Raimi Spider-Man Movie Would Have Continued His Trilogy’s Success

See more : Is Turn of the Tide on Netflix Based on a True Story?

Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man trilogy has gone down in history as a landmark piece of superhero cinema. 2002’s Spider-Man and the 2004 sequel, Spider-Man 2, set a high bar, and though 2007’s Spider-Man 3 didn’t quite live up to it in quality, it still made a respectable amount at the box office. Sam Raimi originally planned to continue the franchise with a fourth movie, and although Spider-Man 4 was never made, it could have performed well if it had been.

Raimi’s reported plans for Spider-Man 4 were ambitious, but it’s his approach to the other 3 movies that make the canceled film seem so promising. Raimi’s vision and the meticulously built world he established over the span of the trilogy made for an especially rich franchise, and a further entry would only have capitalized on that. Regardless of independent details, three successful movies would mean that Raimi’s Spider-Man 4 would have ruled the box office had it been made.

2 Zack Snyder’s Justice League Sequel Could Have Been Huge

Snyder’s Plans For The DCEU Would Have Translated To Box Office Success

See more : Is Turn of the Tide on Netflix Based on a True Story?

As proven by the MCU’s movie timeline, team-up movies are a big deal. The DCEU’s first attempt at a grand scale crossover in Justice League may not have had the desired effect, but it wasn’t a total disaster. However, Zack Snyder departing halfway through production ultimately led to several issues with the film, and it never received its planned sequels. Had Snyder’s vision been carried out, the Justice League sequels likely would have earned big at the box office.

Capitalizing on the set-up of Darkseid’s arrival on Earth and the dark Knightmare future glimpsed by Batman, Justice League 2 seemed to have a fascinating story to tell. The return of Henry Cavill’s Superman, Ben Affleck’s Batman, and Gal Gadot’s Wonder Woman, as well as their fellow heroes, would only have been a big draw for global audiences. It’s hard to imagine anything but a huge box office take for the DCEU’s Justice League 2 had it come to fruition in line with Snyder’s plans.

1 Superman Lives Could Have Capitalized On Major Star Power

Nicolas Cage As Superman Would Have Been Huge Moment For The Genre

See more : Is Turn of the Tide on Netflix Based on a True Story?

When it comes to canceled comic book movies, few are as well-known as Superman Lives. With many famous names attached to the unmade movie, it’s one of the most high-profile cancelations of a superhero movie in the history of the genre. With a script originally written by Kevin Smith, Tim Burton attached to direct, and Nicolas Cage signed on to play Superman, Superman Lives was once slated for a 1998 release.

Ultimately, Superman Lives swiftly entered production hell and was eventually placed on hold in April 1998. A few more years languishing under creative differences with various writers and directors, and Superman Lives was scrapped altogether. The combination of Nicolas Cage, Tim Burton, Kevin Smith, and the iconic figure of Superman could only ever have been a box office success, making it one of the most hypothetically lucrative canceled movies from the MCU, the DCU, and beyond.

Marvel Cinematic Universe
The Marvel Cinematic Universe is a multimedia superhero franchise that began in 2008 with Paramount’s Iron Man starring Robert Downey Jr. The franchise quickly grew in popularity, with Disney eventually buying out Marvel Entertainment in 2009. The MCU consists of dozens of movies and TV shows, most notably Avengers: Endgame, WandaVision, and Loki.
DC Universe
The DC Universe is one of the biggest comic book franchises and often competes with Marvel. DC Comics started as National Allied Publications, founded by Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson in 1935. Since then, the franchise has exploded with thousands of comic books, movies, TV shows, and video games. 2013 marked the beginning of the most recent iteration of the superheroes, with Zack Snyder introducing Henry Cavill as Superman. After several movies with mixed reviews, DC underwent a soft reboot under the helm of James Gunn and Peter Safran.