10 Horror Movie Heroes Who Were Secretly The Villains

Horror movies quite commonly offer cautionary tales, from Frankenstein’s monster, to families moving into haunted houses despite warnings. Horror movies based on folklore, for example, have premises that carry timeless moral messages. The protagonists’ strengths of character are tested in these films, and they sometimes even end in tragedy, on their way to establishing the importance of being conscientious. This is why horror movie villains sometimes seem to be in the right, like in Carrie, where even though the titular character ends up killing many people, her prior mistreatment at the hands of the deceased makes her actions feel justified.

✕ Remove Ads

Horror films reflect the anxieties of any given era. That’s why there have been so many horror movies about artificial intelligence in recent times. The horror in the more meaningful films are the manifestations of human error, and the consequences of wrongdoing. The best horror movies come with life lessons, not the kind that viewers get beaten over the head with, but the kind that becomes clear through the fates of the characters who make questionable choices at every point in the movie. Hence, the “heroes” of some horror movies might be the real villains, as they usher in devastation.

10 Dana Polk

The Cabin in the Woods (2012)

Your Rating

close10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10 Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

My List My Favorite MoviesMy Watchlist

Success!

8.2/10 The Cabin in the Woods RHorrorComedy

The Cabin in the Woods strictly follows the traditional slasher movie dynamic: a group of teens heads to a remote location for the weekend only to find themselves beset by monsters. However, what they don’t know is that the inevitable horrors they will face have all been arranged by a mysterious team watching from a facility deep underground.

Where to Watch

  • stream
  • rent
  • buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

*Availability in US Release Date April 13, 2012 Runtime 95 minutes Cast Richard Jenkins , Fran Kranz , Chris Hemsworth , Bradley Whitford , Kristen Connolly Director Drew Goddard Writers Drew Goddard , Joss Whedon Studio(s) Lionsgate Distributor(s) Lionsgate Expand

✕ Remove Ads

One can’t be blamed for trying to protect themselves at all costs, especially in a life-or-death situation, but Dana’s choices in The Cabin in the Woods have a deeper impact that makes her actions questionable at best. Firstly, she’s the one responsible for starting the zombie attack by reciting incantations from a diary that would have been better left unread. This might be easy to forgive since they were being watched and would get attacked either way. However, what she does next is less forgivable, making The Cabin in the Woods a movie where people want the villain to win.

It’s difficult not to see her as a villain.

Despite understanding the stakes of the ritual, and why they need to die, Dana and Marty both decide to doom humanity. Marty’s an equal participant, of course, but Dana had the opportunity to put things in motion when asked to shoot Marty, and she didn’t follow through. As a friend, and even as a person with a survival instinct, these are understandable actions, but it’s difficult not to see her as a villain, especially when she knows she’ll die anyway, but her sacrifice might save humanity.

✕ Remove Ads

9 Jill Roberts

Scream 4 (2011)

Scream 4 Movie Poster

Your Rating

close10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10 Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

My List My Favorite MoviesMy Watchlist

Success!

9/10 Scream 4 RHorrorThriller

The fourth entry into the iconic Scream franchise, this slasher sequel chronicles yet another killing spree in the suburban town of Woodsboro. Fifteen years after the events of the original Scream, a copycat killer begins murdering local teens in an attempt to recreate the Ghostface murders. Combining slasher action with mystery and social commentary, Scream 4 reunites franchise mainstays Neve Campbell, Courteney Cox, and David Arquette, along with new characters played by Emma Roberts, Hayden Panettiere, and Rory Culkin.

Where to Watch

  • stream
  • rent
  • buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

*Availability in US Release Date April 15, 2011 Runtime 111 Minutes Cast Courteney Cox , Neve Campbell , David Arquette , Emma Roberts , Hayden Panettiere , Anthony Anderson , Alison Brie , Adam Brody​ , Rory Culkin , Marielle Jaffe Director Wes Craven Writers Kevin Williamson Studio(s) Outerbanks Entertainment , The Weinstein Company Distributor(s) Dimension Films Expand

The Scream franchise is known for its satirical, meta, self-aware take on the slasher genre. Over the years, the Scream films have evolved with the slashers of the era to incorporate newer tropes to subvert or critique through their narratives. But, the best part of every Scream film remains the reveal of its Ghostface. Predictable or not, the reveal is always an entertaining moment for the reactions it elicits from the characters and because it often reflects on the latest generation through the motivation of the killer.

Emma Roberts as Jill in Scream 4 Related Emma Roberts Would Consider Scream Franchise Return As Jill

Scream 4’s Emma Roberts shares in an interview that she would consider returning as Jill, and feels she isn’t done with the hit franchise.

Posts
✕ Remove Ads

One of the more surprising Ghostface reveals is in Scream 4. It’s particularly shocking because, while the killers are almost always one of the new characters, a direct relative of Sidney Prescott is a diabolical choice. Emma Roberts’ performance up until the reveal carries foreshadowing that becomes more apparent on a rewatch, but it’s still hard to not feel enraged every time one watches that revelation occur. It takes a horrible person to force one’s sister to revisit her worst trauma just out of envy of her unwanted fame from being a victim, which makes Jill Roberts the best Ghostface.

8 Juno Kaplan

The Descent (2005)

Your Rating

close10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10 Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

My List My Favorite MoviesMy Watchlist

Success!

10/10 The Descent RHorrorAdventureThriller

The Descent is a horror film that follows a group of thrill-seeking friends who find themselves fractured after one of them loses their husband and daughter in a car accident. Attempting to rejuvenate her friend Sarah and bring her back to the group, Juno convinces her to follow her and their friends to a mysterious cave system they find in the mountains. However, when they find themselves traped with no way out, she reveals she took them to an uncharted region with no chance of rescue, hoping to give them the adventure of the life time. Angry, fearful, and low on supplies, the group travels further into the caves only to discover they’re not alone.

Where to Watch

  • stream
  • rent
  • buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

*Availability in US Release Date August 4, 2006 Runtime 99 minutes Cast Shauna Macdonald , Saskia Mulder , Alex Reid , Natalie Mendoza , MyAnna Buring , Nora-Jane Noone Director Neil Marshall Writers Neil Marshall Studio(s) Lionsgate Distributor(s) Lionsgate Expand

✕ Remove Ads

One of the more common emotional themes in horror movies is grief. It becomes the source of horror for some characters, and almost always motivates choices that are questionable choices. And sometimes, the actions seem justifiable, since it’s unfair to entirely dismiss a grieving person as a villain for not finding the best way to cope with their loss. For example, one of the harsh realities of rewatching the Friday the 13th movies is realizing that Pamela Voorhees as a grieving, vengeful mother is a better killer than Jason Voorhees, whose motivation feels weaker.

When Juno dies in
The Descent: Part 2
, it’s a bitter moment in the film, but considering everything she’s done, it feels less sad than the other deaths.

However, the same can’t be said of Juno Kaplan from the The Descent duology. Not only does she actively endanger her friends for adventure, but she also sleeps with her closest friend’s husband. Irrespective of her grief, both decisions are incredibly selfish, and not easy to forgive, even though she risks her life to save the friend’s life later. Plus, she abandons one of her other friends to her fate after she herself fatally wounds her. Calling her a villain might seem excessive, but she’s the reason her friends are exposed to the murderous monsters in the first place.

✕ Remove Ads

7 Ellison Oswalt

Sinister (2012)

Your Rating

close10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10 Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

My List My Favorite MoviesMy Watchlist

Success!

8.3/10 Sinister RThrillerHorrorMystery

Sinister is a supernatural horror movie that centers around a washed-up true-crime writer named Ellison Oswalt, who finds a box of Super 8 home movies that suggest the murder he is currently researching is the work of a serial killer whose macabre work dates back to the 1960s. As he begins to write a biography about the case, terrifying images start to seep into his consciousness, making him question reality as the horrors of old are made new again.

Where to Watch

  • stream
  • rent
  • buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

*Availability in US Release Date October 12, 2012 Runtime 110 minutes Cast Juliet Rylance , Ethan Hawke , Fred Dalton Thompson , Vincent D’Onofrio , James Ransone Director Scott Derrickson Writers Scott Derrickson , C. Robert Cargill Studio(s) Lionsgate Distributor(s) Lionsgate Expand

Ellison possibly takes the top prize among the people who intentionally move into cursed houses. His motivation makes him the worst of the lot. He isn’t there out of curiosity or on a dare, he’s there to monetize the haunting through his writing. His greed eventually dooms his family because living there marks them for death. His shady choices are the ultimate form of selfishness, as he ignores ominous occurrences to improve his career, and doesn’t take any steps toward keeping his family safe until it’s too late.


Sinister’s macabre story introduced audiences to director Scott Derrickson’s otherworldly ‘Bughuul’ figure, which has since become a famous movie monster, spawning a sequel to the film that was released in 2015.
” –
Mark Birrell
– 10 Best Horror Movies Like Sinister

✕ Remove Ads

Ellison doesn’t just become aware of the possibilities much earlier than he does anything about them, his reaction to the discovery is to withhold information from law enforcement. He wants to use the evidence of killings he finds in the attic to create a plot for his next novel, mentally conjuring a serial killer to explain the footage he finds. He actively ignores the inexplicable phenomena in the attic and, eventually, gets his family killed. He may not be the killer, and there may be a monster involved, but he’s the villain for his family at least.

6 Adelaide Wilson/Red

Us (2019)

Your Rating

close10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10 Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

My List My Favorite MoviesMy Watchlist

Success!

8.5/10 Us RHorrorMysteryThriller

Written and directed by Jordan Peele, Us follows the Wilson family; Adelaide (Lupita Nyong’o) and her husband Gabe (Winston Duke), and their children, Zora (Shahadi Wright Joseph) and Jason (Evan Alex). When visiting a remote lakeside cabin, the Wilson family is beset by exact doppelgangers of themselves, who quickly disclose that they mean their counterparts harm. The Wilson family is forced to fight for their lives against twisted mirror images of themselves, not realizing that there are more doppelgangers out there.

Release Date March 22, 2019 Runtime 116 Minutes Cast Lupita Nyong’o , Winston Duke , Elisabeth Moss , Tim Heidecker , Shahadi Wright Joseph , Evan Alex , Yahya Abdul-Mateen II , Anna Diop Director Jordan Peele Writers Jordan Peele Studio(s) Universal Pictures Distributor(s) Universal Pictures Main Genre Horror Expand

✕ Remove Ads

Jordan Peele is known for making horror movies that tackle social issues, like systemic racism in Get Out, and capitalism in Nope. He’s also known for including a twist in the movie that makes viewers reassess everything that’s happened until then. Us metaphorically explores the concept of classism through the story of the tethered, who are identical to the untethered or regular people, but are forced to live underground in hiding and feed on rabbits, while their doppelgängers above get to live regular lives. The contrast in privilege makes one wonder if the villains are even unjustified.

Lupita Nyongo in Us with Red in background Related Us’ Tethered Explained: Government Creation, Underground Tunnels & Purpose

The existence of the Tethered and their tunnels is a bit of a mystery in Us. Here’s everything we know about why the government created them.

Posts

The plot twist in Us is obvious, but that doesn’t detract from the horror of the situation. Since Adelaide is really her tethered self living in the outside world, that means she didn’t just take over the life of her doppelgänger, she discovered a way to get the privileges that the other tethered don’t have access to, but didn’t attempt to help them through. While she doesn’t seem to be a danger to her regular family because she’s detached from the tethered and protects her children, if the tethered are to be considered victims, she’s definitely a villain.

✕ Remove Ads

5 Christian Hughes

Midsommar (2019)

Your Rating

close10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10 Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

My List My Favorite MoviesMy Watchlist

Success!

22 7/10 Midsommar RMysteryDramaHorror

Ari Aster’s Midsommar follows a group of American college students who travel to a friend’s isolated rural hometown in Sweden to experience their renowned midsummer festival. What starts out as idyllic quickly becomes a disconcertingly violent pagan ritual, with the friends engaged in a ruthless competition that will test more than just their friendship. Florence Pugh stars alongside Jack Reynor, Will Poulter, and William Jackson Harper.

Release Date July 3, 2019 Runtime 147 minutes Cast Julia Ragnarsson , Rebecka Johnston , Henrik Norlén , William Jackson Harper , Gunnel Fred , Anna Åström , Will Poulter , Archie Madekwe , Louise Peterhoff , Björn Andrésen , Isabelle Grill , Jack Reynor , Florence Pugh , Liv Mjönes Director Ari Aster Writers Ari Aster Main Genre Horror Expand

Ari Aster’s horror films deal with grief. The main characters in each of them are coping with a loss and go through harrowing experiences during their journey to acceptance. The protagonist of Midsommar is dealing with the death of her family when she goes to visit the Swedish midsummer festival. Her boyfriend, Christian, believes the experience could help take her mind off things, and he insists on that to a toxic extent. He’s so toxic that his death at the end still makes Midsommar one of the movies with “good for her” endings.

Christian’s “sex” scene might have given his girlfriend a panic attack, but he was drugged and then non-consensually made to have sex. He’s a victim in the situation and not a cheater.

✕ Remove Ads

Christian spends the majority of the time at the festival flirting with other women and gaslighting his girlfriend when she confronts him. He ignores her when she tells him that she’s uncomfortable with the rituals being performed at the festival. He even claims that her grief makes her a killjoy, and he needs to spend time away from her. The sex ritual he has in the third act becomes the breaking point for his girlfriend, but he deserves sympathy for being forced into it. However, the rest of his misconduct still makes him a villain to her.

4 Grace Stewart

The Others (2001)

the others poster

Your Rating

close10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10 Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

My List My Favorite MoviesMy Watchlist

Success!

The Others PG-13MysteryThrillerHorror

Alejandro Amenábar wrote and directed this cult-classic 2001 Horror film starring Nicole Kidman and Fionnula Flanagan. The premise follows a mother and her two young photosensitive children as they attempt to deal with a mysterious and possibly sinister presence in their New Jersey home.

Where to Watch

  • stream
  • rent
  • buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

*Availability in US Release Date August 10, 2001 Runtime 104 minutes Cast Nicole Kidman , James Bentley , Alakina Mann , Christopher Eccleston , Fionnula Flanagan Director Alejandro Amenábar Writers Alejandro Amenábar Studio(s) StudioCanal Distributor(s) Warner Bros. Pictures , StudioCanal , Dimension Films Expand

✕ Remove Ads

M. Night Shyamalan’s The Sixth Sense has one of the most famous ending twists in movie history, which has become so iconic that reveals of the sort are referred to as “M. Night Shyamalan twists.” In the same vein, Alejandro Amenábar’s The Others has an M. Night Shyamalan twist, and it’s revealed similarly to The Sixth Sense. Much like Bruce Willis’ character in The Sixth Sense, Nicole Kidman’s character is revealed in the ending of The Others to have been dead all along, and a ghost.

The final reveal cements her as the villain of the film.

Grace responds to being haunted by spirits in her house in quite an extreme fashion. After finding a woman in her daughter’s dress, she attacks her, and then discovers it’s her daughter she has attacked. Her behavior borders on paranoia the whole time, and then the final reveal cements her as the villain of the film. She coped with the loss of her husband by murdering her children in cold blood and then killing herself. Now, she’s a ghost who haunts the living residents of her house.

✕ Remove Ads

3 Marie

High Tension (2003)

Your Rating

close10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10

Your comment has not been saved

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

My List My Favorite MoviesMy Watchlist

Success!

High Tension RHorror Release Date June 10, 2005 Runtime 85 minutes Cast Philippe Nahon , Maïwenn , Oana Pellea , Cecile de France , Andrei Finti Director Alexandre Aja Writers Alexandre Aja , Grégory Levasseur

Slasher movies are characterized by memorable villains who viewers will believe are impossible to beat, and a final girl, albeit a sex-negative and regressive trope, who the audience will again believe can somehow actually outsmart the killer. Alexandre Aja’s High Tension blurs the boundaries between the two characters for a fantastic twist ending. However, the ending simply makes High Tension a problematic slasher that demonizes both queerness and mental illness. The unrealized potential and the regressive politics make it one of the most controversial slashers of all time.


The twist ending of Haute Tension never sat right with critics, as many reviewers felt that its outlandish revelations undid a lot of the movie’s effective tension and suspense.
” –
Cathal Gunning
– ScreenRant

✕ Remove Ads

High Tension has the makings of the perfect slasher – it is fast-paced, it has almost cartoonishly gory kills, and the final girl is flawed in her efforts to survive, but manages some moments of genius as she prepares to face the killer. But, then, it’s revealed at the end that the “hero”, Marie, is a lesbian who is acting on her homosexual urges that society demonizes, by killing people so cold-bloodedly in such horrifying ways. Her dissociative identity disorder is used to justify her villainy, but that’s a harmful form of representation, of both mental illness and queerness!

2 Driver

No One Lives (2013)

No One Lives Movie Poster

Your Rating

close10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10

Your comment has not been saved

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

My List My Favorite MoviesMy Watchlist

Success!

No One Lives RHorrorThriller Where to Watch

  • stream
  • rent
  • buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

*Availability in US Release Date March 9, 2013 Runtime 86 minutes Cast Luke Evans , Adelaide Clemens , Derek Magyar , Beau Knapp , America Olivo , Lee Tergesen Director Ryuhei Kitamura Writers David Cohen Main Genre Horror Expand

✕ Remove Ads

Wanting to avenge one’s wife’s death can hardly be considered grounds for calling someone a villain, but Driver’s bloodlust makes that possible. While he seems like the victim in the beginning, it is impossible to feel sympathy for him after it’s revealed that he has a penchant for killing people for no reason. The fact that he has a girl locked up in the trunk of his car, who is the sole survivor of a group of fifteen, all of whom were clearly killed by Driver, clearly makes him the villain.

While the man who initially stops Driver and provides his wife the means to kill herself is a criminal, and does deserve punishment for his actions, his or his family’s fate seem unfair. Driver kills each of them brutally, using the most horrifying tools and means to torture them before killing them. He’s a methodical psychopath, so, even if he’s the victim initially and the group of people he kills are all ruthless criminals, he’s definitely the villain in No One Lives .

✕ Remove Ads

1 Amanda Young

Saw II (2005)

Saw 2 2005 Movie Poster

Your Rating

close10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10 Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

My List My Favorite MoviesMy Watchlist

Success!

Saw 2 RHorrorMysteryThriller

Saw II is the follow-up to James Wan and Leigh Whannell’s 2004 body horror film, Saw. In the sequel, a group of ex-convicts are kidnapped by Jigsaw and must work together to find an antidote to a toxin that is scheduled to kill them all in two hours. Darren Lynn Bousman took over directing duties for Saw II after Wan directed the original.

Release Date October 28, 2005 Runtime 93 Minutes Cast Donnie Wahlberg Director darren lynn bousman , Franky G , Glenn Plummer , Beverley Mitchell , Dina Meyer , Emmanuelle Vaugier , Erik Knudsen , Shawnee Smith , Tobin Bell Writers darren lynn bousman , Leigh Whannell Studio(s) Lionsgate Distributor(s) Universal Pictures , Lionsgate Expand

Viewers of the Saw franchise who have kept up with the films now know her as Jigsaw’s assistant who kept his legacy going after his death, but Amanda wasn’t always on his side of the traps. She’s the only known survivor of a Jigsaw trap in Saw II, and hence, the only person who’s been forced to play his sick game twice. Her will to survive becomes apparent as the game progresses, as she manages to make the sacrifices necessary at every step to help a child survive, as one by one, the participants start dying.

Tobin Bell as Jigsaw gazing at a victim in Saw X Related Saw 11’s Jigsaw Return Confirmed By Franchise Star: “John Kramer Is Not Done”

Tobin Bell, who plays Jigsaw in the horror franchise, confirms that the iconic villain is set to appear in the upcoming 2025 sequel Saw XI.

Posts

✕ Remove Ads

However, the Saw movies are known for their shocking twists, and it’s revealed that the game is days old. Daniel’s father rushes to find him still alive, but before he can do anything, he’s attacked by Amanda. She had become Jigsaw’s assistant after surviving his game, and was an accomplice in the game all along. Everything that happened was predestined, and no one can save him now either. For those who consider Jigsaw justified in his games, Amanda is perhaps in the right too. But within the rules of a horror film, her role is eventually that of a villain.

Leave a Comment