Lacey Chabert’s 10 Best Christmas Movies, Ranked

Some of those unfamiliar with Lacey Chabert’s work over on the Hallmark Channel might be discovering her for the first time after watching her in Hot Frosty on Netflix, but Chabert is a certified Christmas movie queen. The actress has starred in countless holiday films over the years, mostly on the Hallmark Channel. However, some of Chabert’s roles in the movies are more memorable than others, making them stand out amongst the rest, which is a feat, given that the actress has appeared in more than 15 festive flicks.

✕ Remove Ads

Despite her tireless work on Christmas projects year after year, many will first recognize Chabert from her iconic role as Gretchen Wieners in Mean Girls alongside Lindsay Lohan, Rachel McAdams, and Amanda Seyfried. Almost a decade following her breakthrough via the memorable 2000s chick flick, though, Chabert turned to Hallmark. Since the early 2010s, Chabert has made her mark in the world of Hallmark holiday (and non-holiday) films, and in 2024, she joined the Netflix Christmas movie universe.

10 Matchmaker Santa

Release Date: November 17, 2012

Close

✕ Remove Ads

Matchmaker Santa is one of Lacey Chabert’s first Hallmark Channel Christmas movies, and its nostalgia and stereotypical cheesy holiday film premise make it one of her best. It’s hard not to feel joy when watching the 2012 festive rom-com. Matchmaker Santa features predictable tropes, palpable chemistry, and Santa Claus (of course), but none of these are bad things (especially for those who love a good Hallmark film).

Lacey Chabert in Hot Frosty and Lindsay Lohan in Falling For Christmas Related Hot Frosty’s Lindsay Lohan & Lacey Chabert Mean Girls Nod Creates A Big Opportunity For Netflix’s Christmas Movie Universe

Hot Frosty, starring Lacey Chabert, includes a Mean Girls Easter egg, and further links the streaming service’s Chrismas movie universe.

In Matchmaker Santa, Chabert stars as Melanie Hogan. Melanie is a bakery owner and dating an insanely handsome CEO named Justin. So, everything in her life must be perfect, right? Wrong. Something feels off in her relationship with Justin, and Melanie starts to realize that when she starts spending a lot of time with her boyfriend’s best friend, Dean, over the holidays. A good, old-fashioned love triangle mixed with the magic of Christmas equals a thoroughly entertaining holiday affair in Matchmaker Santa​​​​​​. The film also features a couple of Hollywood icons — Florence Henderson and John Ratzenberger — making it all the better.

✕ Remove Ads

9 Pride, Prejudice, & Mistletoe

Release Date: November 23, 2018

As the title suggests, Pride, Prejudice, and Mistletoe is a take on the classic Jane Austen tale Pride and Prejudice. While it might not live up to other interpretations of Austen’s story (like Joe Wright’s 2005 Oscar-nominated film), it perfectly encapsulates Pride and Prejudice‘s spirit in the vessel of a cheesy Hallmark Christmas movie. Chabert stars as Darcy, a successful businesswoman who returns to her hometown, where she bumps into her former rival, Luke, played by Brendan Penny.

For those who absolutely adore the enemies-to-lovers trope in movies and TV (which
Pride and Prejudice
undoubtedly does best), Chabert’s
Pride, Prejudice, and Mistletoe
is the perfect Christmas movie.

✕ Remove Ads

As fate would have it, Darcy and Luke are forced to work together to plan a charity event. As time goes on, and they get to know one another better, one thing leads to another, and, all of a sudden, their hate turns into love. Hate and love are two sides of the same coin, after all. For those who absolutely adore the enemies-to-lovers trope in movies and TV (which Pride and Prejudice undoubtedly does best), Chabert’s Pride, Prejudice, and Mistletoe is the perfect Christmas movie.

8 Hot Frosty

Release Date: November 13, 2024

Close

Hot Frosty - Poster

Your Rating

10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10 Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

ScreenRant logo 5/10 7/10 Hot Frosty RomanceComedyHoliday

Two years after losing her husband, Kathy magically brings a snowman to life. His innocence and charm help her reconnect with joy and love. As their bond deepens over the holiday season, a budding romance develops, but they are faced with the reality that the snowman will soon melt.

Director Jerry Ciccoritti Release Date November 13, 2024 Writers Russell Hainline Cast Lacey Chabert , Dustin Milligan , Katy Mixon Greer , Joe Lo Truglio , Craig Robinson , Lauren Holly , Chrishell Stause , Sherry Miller , Dan Lett , Matthew Stefiuk , Heleene Lohan Cameron , Allan Royal , Sarah Desouza-Coelho , Bobby Daniels Expand
✕ Remove Ads

Even though Hot Frosty is the latest installment in the Lacey Chabert Christmas movie universe (and as a result might suffer from some recency bias), it’s still one of her best. Perhaps on the outside, the 2024 fantasy rom-com might seem like one of Chabert’s most corny holiday flicks. A film about a snowman who comes to life and falls in love is bound to be cheesy, after all. However, by the end of Hot Frosty, it’s clear that it has a lot of heart and is deeper than anyone could have predicted.

Hot Frosty Cast

Role

Lacey Chabert

Kathy Barrett

Dustin Milligan

Jack Snowman

Katy Mixon

Dottie

Lauren Holly

Jane Miller

Jo Lo Truglio

Deputy Sheriff Ed Schatz

Craig Robinson

Sheriff Nathaniel Hunter

Dan Lett

Theo

Sherry Miller

Mel

Chrishell Strause

Jan

✕ Remove Ads

Hot Frosty features tragedy and grief mixed with a whole lot of Christmas magic. For the most part, it’s a happy tale, but it has complex layers due to Kathy’s backstory and struggle to move on from her loss. Plus, Dustin Milligan is a delight as Jack in the cast of Hot Frosty — it’s hard not to smile when he’s on the screen.

7 Family For Christmas

Release Date: July 11, 2015

Lacey Chabert and Tyron Leitso in Family for Christmas

Family for Christmas tells the classic story of “what if,” meaning what someone’s life could have been like if they picked a different path. For Lacey Chabert’s Hannah Dunbar, she wonders what would have happened to her if she stayed with the love of her life, Ben, instead of choosing her career. Santa Claus grants Hannah’s wish, and all of a sudden, she is back with Ben, and they have kids together.

✕ Remove Ads

Violent Night, Klaus, and Jingle Jangle Related 17 Best Christmas Movies Of The Last Decade, Ranked

From Krampus to Klaus, these festive favorites were the best Christmas movies of the past decade.

Family for Christmas is a fun, yet emotional Hallmark Christmas movie to watch. It can leave viewers torn about what the right path is for Chabert’s character, making for an intriguing story that is bound to tug at one’s heartstrings. It’s also nice to see a holiday film that’s not 100 percent about romance.

6 Time For Us To Come Home For Christmas

Release Date: December 5, 2020

✕ Remove Ads

If one is tired of the stereotypical Hallmark Christmas movie that follows tired and common tropes, Time for Us to Come Home for Christmas is the ideal watch. It’s also great for those who love a mystery. In the film, five people (including Lacey Chabert’s Sarah) receive strange invitations to celebrate the holidays together at an inn. They must work together to discover what connects them and why they, specifically, were chosen.

Of course, Time for Us to Come Home for Christmas has a bit of romance. However, it’s the mystery aspect of the 2020 festive flick that separates it from the rest. Who wouldn’t love a good ole Hallmark Christmas movie that is defined by solving a mystery but also has plenty of romance? For those reasons alone, Time for Us to Come Home for Christmas ranks among Chabert’s best Christmas movies.

5 A Christmas Melody

Release Date: December 19, 2015

Close
✕ Remove Ads

The name Mariah Carey has essentially become synonymous with Christmas. So, a Hallmark Christmas movie featuring Carey and Lacey Chabert (one of the best Hallmark Christmas movie actresses) has to rank among the best, and A Christmas Melody sure does. The 2015 film revolves around Chabert’s Kristin, a single mother and a clothing designer whose financial situation forces her to move her and her daughter back to her hometown.

A Christmas Melody Cast

Role

Lacey Chabert

Kristin Frank

Mariah Carey

Melissa Atkinson

Brennan Elliot

Danny Collier

Fina Strazza

Emily Frank

Kathy Najimy

Sarah

✕ Remove Ads

Kristin’s daughter, Emily, has a tough time with the move, which is why Chabert’s character enlists the help of Emily’s music teacher, Danny. Meanwhile, Carey’s Melissa serves as Kristin’s rival, trying to make her life harder than it already is. Ultimately, the power of love, music, and Christmas shines through and makes A Christmas Melody one of Chabert’s most feel-good films.

4 The Sweetest Christmas

Release Date: November 11, 2017

Lacey Chabert has played numerous cooks and bakers over the course of her Christmas movie career. However, The Sweetest Christmas is undoubtedly her best performance as one. The 2017 holiday romance film follows Chabert’s Kylie Watson, a pastry chef competing in the American Gingerbread Competition. She hopes that the contest will help her achieve her dream of opening a cafe. However, things go terribly wrong when her oven breaks.

✕ Remove Ads

Aside from Lacey Chabert, the cast of
The Sweetest Christmas
includes Lea Coco as Nick and Jonathan Adams as Ralphie.

Kylie receives some help from her ex-boyfriend, Nick, though. The two must work together to make Kylie’s dreams come true (and perhaps to fall back in love). For those passionate about baking, romance, and Hallmark holiday movies with happy endings,The Sweetest Christmas satisfies all.

3 A Royal Christmas

Release Date: November 21, 2014

Close

✕ Remove Ads

A Christmas Prince might have kick-started Netflix’s holiday movie universe in 2017, but A Royal Christmas came first in 2014. Chabert stars as Emily Corrigan, a seamstress who comes from a working-class family and is quite in love with her European boyfriend, Leo. However, she is shocked to learn that Leo is actually Leopold, a prince from Cordinia who is next in line for the throne.

Your Rating

10 stars9 stars8 stars7 stars6 star5 stars4 stars3 stars2 stars1 star Rate Now 0/10

Your comment has not been saved

A Royal Christmas TV-G Where to Watch

  • stream
  • rent
  • buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

*Availability in US Director Alex Zamm Release Date November 21, 2014 Cast Lacey Chabert , Jane Seymour Main Genre Romantic Comedy

A Royal Christmas is a staple in Chabert’s Christmas movie filmography as it is one of her most memorable projects. As mentioned above, it came three years before A Christmas Prince premiered on Netflix and became a hit so big that the streaming service just kept on producing original holiday films. So, Hallmark’s movie A Royal Christmas is the original cheesy Christmas story about an ordinary woman falling in love with a prince, and it has Jane Seymour in it, so, it’s safe to say that it’s one of Chabert’s best.

✕ Remove Ads

2 Christmas In Rome

Release Date: November 30, 2019

Close

Christmas in Rome undoubtedly gets a boost from its setting — what could be more romantic or exciting than a Hallmark Christmas movie in Rome? Italy is one of the best places to spend the holidays, after all. However, the 2019 film also features a thoughtful and layered love story that is unlike many Hallmark romances. For that reason and the Rome backdrop, Christmas in Rome is at the top of Chabert’s list of festive flicks.

Best Christmas Movies Related 29 Best Christmas Movies Of All Time

Time to get into the Christmas spirit with a run down of the best Christmas movies of all time.

✕ Remove Ads

Chabert stars as Angela, an American tour guide, in Christmas in Rome. After she loses her job, Angela bumps into Oliver, an American executive played by Sam Page, who is in Rome trying to buy an Italian ceramics company. Oliver enlists Angela’s help to show him around the beautiful historic city. While Angela and Oliver can’t help but fall in love with one another, they also fall in love with Rome, which is a significant reason why Christmas in Rome is one of Chabert’s best Hallmark Christmas movies.

1 Christmas Waltz

Release Date: November 28, 2020

✕ Remove Ads

Christmas Waltz is arguably Lacey Chabert’s superior holiday film. The 2020 Hallmark Channel Christmas movie tells a unique, heartfelt, memorable story and features one of the actress’ best romantic pairings. Chabert has great chemistry with Will Kemp, especially on the dance floor, and it’s a joy to watch their characters fall in love over the course of Christmas Waltz​​​​​​.

Christmas Waltz Cast

Role

Lacey Chabert

Avery

Will Kemp

Roman

Katrina Reynolds

Molly

Jeremy Guilbaut

David

Julia Harnett

Elina

John Talan Church

Nicky

Beatrice King

Darna

Laura Soltis

Evelyn

Fred Henderson

Fergus

Marco Soriano

Jimmy

Tasha Simms

Nina

Lane Edwards

Bob

✕ Remove Ads

Chabert portrays Avery, a woman whose fiancé leaves her one month before their picturesque Christmas wedding, in Christmas Waltz​​​​​​. To pick herself up from her heartbreak, Avery decides to take the dance lessons intended for her wedding anyway. She meets her instructor, Roman, who grants Avery her dream of becoming a dancer (and he changes her whole world, of course). If someone were to watch just one of Lacey Chabert’s Christmas movies after checking out Hot Frosty on Netflix, it should be Christmas Waltz​​​​​​.

Leave a Comment